Satoshi's 'Educated Guess' Now Produces Lower Inflation Than Gold

By
Giannis Andreou
February 27, 2026
4
Min Read
Share:

Of the 21 million bitcoin that will ever exist, roughly 19.9 million have already been mined as of early 2026—about 95% of total supply. Only 1.1 million remain, and the last fraction won't enter circulation until approximately 2140. The fixed supply cap is treated as Bitcoin's most defining property, the feature that separates it from every fiat currency on Earth. But the number itself was never derived from a deep mathematical formula. Satoshi Nakamoto, Bitcoin's pseudonymous creator, called the choice an "educated guess" in emails that surfaced during a 2024 London court case involving Craig Wright. That guess, paired with a halving schedule that cuts new issuance in half every four years, has produced something remarkable: a monetary policy with an annual inflation rate of just 0.83% following the April 2024 halving—lower than gold's estimated 1.5–2% annual supply growth for the first time in history.

What Satoshi's Emails Actually Reveal About the Number

The most direct evidence of Satoshi's reasoning comes from email correspondence with early Bitcoin contributor Martti Malmi, made public in February 2024. In those messages, Nakamoto wrote that his choice for the number of coins and distribution schedule was an "educated guess" and that it was "a difficult choice, because once the network is going it's locked in and we're stuck with it." A separate exchange with developer Mike Hearn, published by The Next Web, added context. Nakamoto explained he wanted Bitcoin's unit prices to eventually align with traditional currencies—envisioning a world where 0.001 BTC might equal 1 Euro—and settled on something in the middle.

The 21 million figure wasn't arbitrary, but it wasn't precisely calculated either. It falls out naturally from the parameters Satoshi chose for Bitcoin's reward schedule: an initial block reward of 50 BTC, halved every 210,000 blocks (roughly four years), with blocks produced approximately every 10 minutes. Run that geometric series to its mathematical limit, and the total supply converges to 20,999,999.9769 BTC—not a round 21 million, but close enough. The cap is really a byproduct of the issuance schedule rather than the other way around. Satoshi picked the reward structure first, and the number followed.

Bitcoin supply curve chart showing 21 million hard cap with halving events marked at 2012, 2016, 2020, and 2024 and current 19.9 million BTC position highlighted in green
Bitcoin's asymptotic supply curve from 2009 to 2140. Roughly 19.9 million of the 21 million total have been mined as of 2026, with halving events marked at 2012, 2016, 2020, 2024, and projected 2028. Source: Blockchain.com

Four Halvings Have Compressed New Supply to a Trickle

The mechanism that enforces Bitcoin's scarcity is the halving—a hard-coded event that slashes the block reward by 50% every 210,000 blocks. Four halvings have occurred so far, each one cutting the rate of new bitcoin entering circulation. The first halving on November 28, 2012 dropped the block reward from 50 BTC to 25 BTC when Bitcoin traded at roughly $12. The second on July 9, 2016 reduced it to 12.5 BTC at around $650. The third on May 11, 2020 cut it to 6.25 BTC during COVID-era monetary expansion. The most recent on April 20, 2024 brought the reward down to 3.125 BTC per block, with Bitcoin near $64,968.

Bar chart showing Bitcoin block reward dropping from 50 BTC at genesis to 3.125 BTC after the 2024 halving with daily issuance declining and projected 2028 and 2032 halvings
Block reward reduction across all four halvings from 50 BTC to 3.125 BTC per block, with daily issuance overlay. Projected 2028 and 2032 halvings shown in blue. Source: Glassnode

Today, miners add approximately 450 BTC per day to the circulating supply, or about 164,250 BTC per year. That translates to an annualized inflation rate of roughly 0.83%, based on the circulating supply of ~19.9 million BTC. The fifth halving is projected for approximately April 2028 at block height 1,050,000, which will reduce the block reward to 1.5625 BTC—dropping annual issuance to under 82,125 BTC per year. By the sixth halving around 2032, an estimated 98% of all Bitcoin will have been mined.

Fiat Expansion Makes the Contrast Sharper

Bitcoin's tightening supply stands in sharp contrast to fiat monetary systems. The U.S. M2 money supply hit a record $22.44 trillion in January 2026, growing at 4.3% year-over-year according to Federal Reserve data. Between January 2020 and early 2022, Federal Reserve quantitative easing pushed M2 from roughly $15.4 trillion to over $21.7 trillion—a 40% increase in two years. The Mises Institute noted that more than two-thirds of the current U.S. money supply has been created since 2008.

Bitcoin's protocol makes this kind of expansion structurally impossible. No central authority can alter the issuance schedule. The supply curve is written into open-source code that roughly 97% of Bitcoin nodes enforce, and any modification would require a Bitcoin Improvement Proposal, majority node consensus, and broad community support—a scenario widely considered functionally impossible given that scarcity is central to every holder's investment thesis.

Dual panel chart showing U.S. M2 money supply surge to 22 trillion dollars alongside Bitcoin annual inflation rate declining below gold after the 2024 halving
Left: U.S. M2 money supply growth from $7.8 trillion to $22.4 trillion with the 2020–2022 QE spike highlighted. Right: Bitcoin's declining inflation rate across each halving epoch versus gold's steady ~1.7%, with the historic crossover in the 2024–2028 period. Sources: FRED, Glassnode

The Software Caveat That Won't Go Away

Skeptics rightly point out that the 21 million cap exists in software, not physics. In December 2024, BlackRock included a disclaimer in a Bitcoin explainer video stating that there are no guarantees Bitcoin's maximum supply won't change. Technically, that's true—Bitcoin is open-source code, and a developer could submit a proposal to modify the cap. But the governance hurdles make this practically unachievable: thousands of decentralized node operators would need to upgrade to rules that directly dilute their own holdings.

There's also the question of effective supply versus theoretical supply. CoinLedger's August 2025 research estimates that between 3 and 3.7 million BTC are permanently lost—stuck in wallets with forgotten private keys, destroyed hardware, or inaccessible early addresses. That includes Satoshi Nakamoto's own stash of nearly 1 million BTC, untouched since mining ceased around 2010. The CoinShares analysis argues the effective hard cap is closer to 18.5 million BTC when accounting for lost coins—making Bitcoin even scarcer than the protocol suggests on paper.

Stacked bar chart breaking down Bitcoin effective supply showing 21 million cap 19.9 million mined 3.5 million lost 1 million Satoshi coins and 15.4 million circulating
Effective circulating supply breakdown: 21 million total cap minus 19.9 million mined, minus 3.5 million estimated lost, minus 1 million in Satoshi's untouched wallets, leaves approximately 15.4 million BTC effectively circulating. Sources: CoinLedger, CoinShares

A Bet on Code Over Institutions

Satoshi Nakamoto designed a system where monetary policy runs on math instead of meetings. The 21 million cap, born from a self-described guess about global currency pricing, has evolved into the most predictable supply schedule of any widely held asset. Post-2024 halving, Bitcoin's annual issuance rate of 0.83% sits below gold's roughly 1.5–2% annual supply expansion and far below the growth rates of major fiat money supplies. Whether that translates into sustainable value storage or merely creates an artificial scarcity premium remains the open question for the next decade—but the supply mechanics themselves are settled code, verifiable by anyone with a node and an internet connection.

An image of Giannis Andreou
Giannis Andreou
Founder & CEO
Subscribe to newsletter

Subscribe to receive the latest blog posts to your inbox every week.

By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
BTC MINING
bitmern mining promotion
Bitmern Mining promotion

Start investing in your future

You don’t have to guess your way through this new financial era. Start with a book, dive into a course, or step into Bitcoin mining with professional infrastructure behind you. Wherever you begin, the goal is the same: more clarity, more control, and more freedom over your financial life.

GET CONNECTED

Stay ahead of the crypto market

Follow Giannis on your favourite platforms for daily market insights, Bitcoin mining breakdowns, macro commentary, and long-form education.

@gandreou007

@gi.andreou

@giannisandreou

@giannisandreouPOD

@gandreou007

@giannis_andreou

@gandreou007